Side-by-Side Comparisons
Sell the Home vs One Spouse Keeps It
Financial trade-offs, tax implications, and what Utah courts typically order when it comes to the marital home.
Your Three Options
A
Sell and split proceeds
Most common
B
One spouse keeps and refinances
Requires qualifying
C
Deferred sale
Rare — minor children
Option A — Sell and Split
Both spouses agree to sell the home, pay off the mortgage and closing costs, and divide the remaining equity. This is the cleanest option — no future financial entanglement, no refinancing required, cash in hand for both parties.
Financial entanglement after divorceNone
Refinancing requiredNo
Cash available to both spousesYes
Emotional disruptionHigh — both must move
Children's school stabilityMay be disrupted
Tax note: If you've lived in the home as your primary residence for at least 2 of the last 5 years, you may exclude up to $250,000 of capital gains each ($500,000 combined for a married couple filing jointly). This exclusion can disappear after divorce is finalized — consult a CPA before selling.
Option B — One Spouse Keeps It
One spouse buys out the other's equity share and keeps the home. This requires refinancing the mortgage in that spouse's name alone — lenders will not remove a co-borrower without a new loan. The keeping spouse must qualify for the new mortgage based solely on their own income and credit.
Refinancing requiredYes — mandatory
Equity payout to leaving spouseRequired upfront
Children's school stabilityPreserved
Risk if home value dropsBorne by one spouse
Interest rate riskMay be higher than original rate
The refinance problem: Many spouses want to keep the home but cannot qualify for the mortgage alone. If the keeping spouse cannot refinance within the timeframe set in the decree, the court will typically order the home sold. Do not agree to keep the home without first getting pre-qualified by a lender.
How Equity Is Calculated
Estimated home value (from CMA or appraisal)$450,000
Minus: remaining mortgage balance− $280,000
Minus: estimated costs to sell (6–8%)− $31,500
Net equity to divide= $138,500
Each spouse's share (50/50)$69,250
Example only. Costs to sell include agent commissions, title, escrow, and misc. fees. Utah courts also consider whether one spouse contributed premarital equity.
Option C — Deferred Sale (Rare)
In some cases — usually involving young children — courts allow a deferred sale, where the home is not sold until the youngest child turns 18 or finishes high school. One spouse typically continues living in the home with the children; both spouses remain on the mortgage during this period.
Deferred sales keep both spouses financially tied together for years and create ongoing disputes about maintenance, who pays what, and what happens if one spouse stops paying. Utah courts generally disfavor this arrangement unless circumstances strongly justify it.
What Utah Courts Typically Order
Utah is an equitable distribution state — courts divide marital property fairly, which usually means roughly equally. For the marital home, courts consider:
→Whether minor children live in the home and custody arrangement
→Whether one spouse can qualify to refinance
→Each spouse's financial situation and ability to afford upkeep
→Whether one spouse contributed premarital equity or inheritance
→How long the marriage lasted and each party's contribution to the home
If both spouses agree on what to do with the home, courts almost always approve that agreement. Contested home decisions are among the most expensive and time-consuming aspects of divorce litigation.
Save your results
Need help thinking through your home options?
divvi walks you through the numbers and helps you and your spouse document a decision that holds up in court.
◎