Side-by-Side Comparisons
CMA vs Licensed Appraisal
When each is appropriate for valuing your home in a Utah divorce, how courts weigh each, and which fits your situation.
CMA
$0 – $500
Free to low-cost
Who prepares itLicensed real estate agent
Legal standingOpinion of value — not formal
Turnaround1–3 days
Court acceptanceUsually fine for uncontested
Lender acceptedNo
Licensed Appraisal
$400 – $700
Formal report
Who prepares itCertified appraiser (state licensed)
Legal standingUSPAP-compliant formal report
Turnaround5–14 days
Court acceptanceRequired in most contested cases
Lender acceptedYes
What Is a CMA?
A Comparative Market Analysis is a home value estimate prepared by a licensed real estate agent. The agent compares your home to recently sold similar properties ("comps") in your area, adjusts for differences in size, condition, and features, and arrives at an estimated market value.
CMAs are commonly offered free by agents who hope to list your home, or for a small fee ($100–$500) as a standalone service. They are fast, informal, and generally reliable for typical homes in active markets.
A CMA is not the same as an appraisal. It is a professional opinion — not a licensed valuation — and most lenders will not accept it.
What Is a Licensed Appraisal?
A licensed appraisal is a formal written report produced by a state-certified appraiser following USPAP (Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice). The appraiser physically inspects the property, analyzes comps, and delivers a formal report with a defined value and methodology.
Utah courts treat licensed appraisals as expert testimony. In contested divorces, each party may hire their own appraiser, and the court weighs the reports against each other. If values differ significantly, the court may average them, appoint a neutral appraiser, or rely on one it finds more credible.
When Courts Prefer Each
Uncontested divorce, both spouses agree on value
CMA is usually sufficient
If both parties agree to the home value and use it to divide equity, Utah courts generally accept a CMA or even a mutual agreement on value without requiring a formal appraisal.
Uncontested but one spouse is keeping the home
CMA may work, appraisal is safer
If the keeping spouse needs to refinance, the lender will order their own appraisal anyway. A CMA may still be used to agree on equity in the decree.
Contested divorce, spouses disagree on value
Appraisal almost always required
Each spouse typically hires their own licensed appraiser. The competing reports become part of the court record. A CMA alone is unlikely to be persuasive.
New construction or unique/custom property
Appraisal strongly recommended
Comps are harder to find for new builds or unique properties. Appraisers are trained to handle these cases; agents may not have reliable comparables.
When Spouses Disagree on Value
If you and your spouse cannot agree on your home's value, each of you may hire a separate licensed appraiser. This is common and fully expected by Utah courts.
The court may: (1) average the two appraisals, (2) order a third neutral appraisal, or (3) weigh which report it finds more credible based on methodology and the appraiser's qualifications. Expect to spend $800–$1,400 total if both sides get separate appraisals.
Cost-Benefit Analysis
CMA cost$0 – $500
Appraisal cost$400 – $700
Two competing appraisals$800 – $1,400
Court-ordered neutral appraisal$500 – $800 (additional)
Typical Utah home equity at stake$50,000 – $200,000+
Given that most Utah homes have six figures of equity at stake, spending $500–$700 on a licensed appraisal is almost always worth it — even in uncontested cases — if there is any chance you will dispute value later.
Save your results
Not sure which valuation you need?
divvi walks you through your home situation step by step and helps you decide the right approach.
◎